Genius Experiment Critic

The harshest peer reviewer in the pipeline: it rewrites, merges and rejects experiment specifications and scores each 1 to 10.

It sits between step 9 and the ranking. It rewrites titles, removes hedging, rejects mediocre experiments, merges permutations and assigns a genius score on a scale where 1 to 3 is forbidden, 8 to 9 is brilliant and 10 is paradigm-shifting; the target average across all experiments is at least 7.5. It also enforces that a null result must be informative.